The New York Rent Disputes

When Talmudic Law was Cited to Protect Tenants’ Rights

During and after the First World War many American cities experienced severe housing shortages. Numerous landlords took advantage of the demand in the real estate market by increasing rents exorbitantly and evicting those who could not pay. The courts were overwhelmed with eviction proceedings and in April 1920 the New York State Legislature stepped in to remedy the crisis. They imposed various restrictions on landlords but poured oil on the flames by allowing rent increases of up to 25% and declaring that all leases that were not of fixed duration would terminate at the end of September. It meant that landlords could serve eviction notices on tens of thousands of tenants, greatly adding to the housing crisis.

To try to remedy their error the Legislature passed a series of Emergency Rent Laws. They froze eviction proceedings for 2 years and demanded that rent increases had to comply with statutory tests of reasonableness. The landlords pushed back, setting off a flood of law cases in the State courts, the New York Court of Appeals and in some cases, the Supreme Court….. Read More at https://harryfreedman.substack.com/p/the-new-york-rent-disputes

© 2026 Harry Freedman Books